Skip to content
BlogComparison

Client portal or email: which is better for selection approvals?

Summary

  • Short answer: use a client portal for item-by-item approvals on anything you'll order, and keep email for conversation, quick questions and very small projects.
  • Email is familiar and needs no setup, but approvals end up scattered across threads, and it's hard to prove which version of an item was approved.
  • A shared spreadsheet keeps everything in one place but has no reliable approval record and makes it easy to expose trade prices.
  • A portal records each decision on the item it's about, shows the current version, and keeps your trade terms private. It works only if the client actually opens it.
  • We make Inside Outside, which includes a client portal.

Every studio gets approvals somehow. The question is what's left afterwards: a clear record of who approved which item at what price, or a search through three months of email when a client says they never agreed to the brass finish.

We make Inside Outside, which includes a client portal, so we have an interest in this question. This post compares the three common methods (email, a shared spreadsheet, and a portal) on what matters for approvals.

Is a client portal better than email for approvals?

For approving items you're going to order, yes. A portal records each decision on the item it's about and always shows the current version, which email can't do reliably. Email is still better for discussion, for quick one-off questions, and for projects small enough that a single message covers every decision.

How do email, spreadsheets and portals compare?

Email with PDFs or images Shared spreadsheet Client portal
Setup None Build and share a sheet Depends on your software
What the client approves Whatever was in that email or PDF A row, if they edit the right cell A specific item, as it is now
Approval record Scattered across threads A cell value anyone can change A dated decision on each item
Current version Only if you resend Yes, if one sheet is maintained Yes
Keeping trade prices private Yes, if you build the PDF carefully Hard; columns are easy to leave visible Built in, in portals made for designers
Re-approval after a change Send again and hope they notice Easy to miss Often flags that the item changed
Client effort Low, it's their inbox Medium Low to medium, depending on login

How did we compare them?

We compared the methods on what a designer needs from an approval: a clear decision per item, the version it applies to, privacy for trade terms, and how much effort it asks of the client. This is a comparison of approaches based on standard practice, not a survey or a test of specific portal products.

When is email the right choice for approvals?

Email works when there are few decisions, they're simple, and you'll record them somewhere else anyway. It needs no setup, every client already uses it, and it's the best place for conversation.

Pick email if… the project is a single room or a handful of items, you're asking one quick question, or the decision needs discussion more than a click.

Skip email if… you're approving dozens of items across several rooms, prices or finishes are likely to change, or more than one person on the client side is deciding.

Where email breaks down:

  • Decisions get lost in threads. "Love it, but not the blue one" in reply to an email with eleven products has to be decoded later.
  • The version is unclear. If you sent a revised PDF, which one did they approve?
  • Partial replies are common. A client answers about the sofa and says nothing about the lamps.

If you do use email, number every item, ask for a yes or no on each, and record the replies against the items straight away.

Does a shared spreadsheet work for approvals?

It keeps everything in one place, but it's a weak approval record. Anyone with edit access can change a cell, and nothing shows who changed it or which version of the item they saw. It's also easy to share a column you meant to keep private.

Pick a spreadsheet if… you already run the project from one, the client is comfortable in spreadsheets, and you protect or remove private columns.

Skip a spreadsheet if… you need to show later exactly what was approved and when, or you can't risk a client seeing your trade price or markup columns.

To make it safer, keep the client's copy separate from your working sheet, with only client-facing columns, and add a dated approval column that only you fill in, based on what the client tells you.

What does a client portal do better?

A portal records each decision on the item it's about, shows the client the current version, and keeps trade prices and internal notes private. When you change an approved item, a good portal shows that the earlier approval no longer applies.

Pick a portal if… you're approving items you'll order, prices and finishes may change, or several people are deciding.

Skip a portal if… the client won't open it however you ask, or the project is small enough that a single email covers every decision.

What to look for:

  • No account needed, or as little friction as possible. Every signup step is a chance for a busy client to give up.
  • Approve, decline and comment on each item, not just the whole room.
  • One price per item, the price the client pays, with no trade terms visible.
  • A record of who responded and when, including when an item changed after the response.
  • A way to record approvals given by email or in person, so every approval ends up in one place.

What does email still do better than a portal?

Conversation, reach and urgency. Clients read email without being asked to, a reply can explain a decision in a way a click can't, and a portal can't tell a client something is urgent. The portal doesn't replace email; email becomes the way you tell clients the portal has something for them.

Some portals also don't notify you when a client responds, so you still need to check.

How do I move a client from email to a portal?

Send the portal link in an email that says exactly what you need and by when, and keep using email for the conversation around it.

  1. Explain it in one line: "Your selections are here. Approve or decline each item, and leave a comment if you have a question."
  2. Give a deadline with a reason: "by Friday, so the sofa goes into the next production run."
  3. Say who needs to respond, if a couple are deciding together.
  4. Record approvals that still arrive by email on the item, so the record stays complete.

How does Inside Outside handle approvals?

You share chosen schedules through one private link that your client opens in a browser without an account. They can approve, decline or comment on each product, and they see one price per product, never your trade price. Responses appear in the schedule's activity, and you can record approvals given by email or in a meeting, which saves a copy of the product as it was approved. See Share schedules with clients, See client approvals and comments and Record a client approval.

Skip it if… you need email alerts when a client responds, because Inside Outside doesn't send them yet. It also doesn't fit if you want clients to reply to you inside the portal: you reply by email or phone, and the email that sends the link comes from Inside Outside's address, so replies to it don't reach you. Anyone with the link can respond, so send it only to the people deciding.

Frequently asked questions

Is an email approval legally valid?

An email can be good evidence of what a client agreed, but whether it's enough depends on your contract and where you practise. Whatever you use, keep a dated record of who approved which item at what price, and let your contract say how approvals are given.

Will clients actually use a portal?

Clients are more likely to use one that opens from a link without an account, and when you tell them exactly what you need and by when. Keep email as the channel that sends them to it.

Should I stop emailing clients about selections?

No. Use email to tell clients what's ready and to discuss decisions, and use the portal to record the decisions themselves.

What if a client approves by email anyway?

Record it on the item, with the date, their name and a note that it came by email, so all approvals end up in one place.

Try Inside Outside

Your product library, project schedules, and client selections in one workspace.

Get started